Skip to content

Indianapolis, IN 46201 4021 E New York Street

4021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 14021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 24021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 3
24 more
4021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 44021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 54021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 64021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 74021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 84021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 94021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 104021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 114021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 124021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 134021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 144021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 154021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 164021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 174021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 184021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 194021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 204021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 214021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 224021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 234021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 244021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 254021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 264021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 274021 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN - Image 28
Presented By:
  • MLS# 22057345
  • 08/19/2025
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • SQFT • 3,168

Home Details

Stop Renting-Own Your Commercial Property in Tuxedo Park This affordably priced C-3 commercial property offers the perfect opportunity for an owner-occupant or investor looking to establish a presence in one of Indianapolis' fastest-emerging neighborhoods. The block portion of the building was fully remodeled in 2004, featuring a dedicated office area, a 40x14 bay with 9' overhead door, half bath, and an additional storage room. A 40x50 addition, built in 2005, offers open-span space with a 10' power overhead door, making it highly versatile for a wide range of uses. The property is equipped with 4-phase electric service and two high-efficiency gas furnaces to support business operations. Parking includes pads for up to 7 vehicles, with additional on-street parking available. Strategically located at the corner of New York Street and Grant Street in Tuxedo Park, the property sits just east of Fountain Square and Downtown Indianapolis. Tuxedo Park is experiencing strong revitalization, with new businesses, restaurants, and residential developments adding energy to the area. This prime location offers the cost advantages of being on the edge of downtown while keeping your business close to the city's core growth corridors. Indianapolis continues to see robust demand for well-located commercial properties as its downtown expands with new housing, office, and mixed-use projects. With the city's growth pushing eastward, properties like this one are positioned to appreciate in both value and utility. The property is vacant and easy to show-ready for financially qualified buyers to make their move. Don't miss the chance to own your own building in a growing market.
Presented By:

General for 4021 E New York Street

CityIndianapolis
CountyMarion
Current UseComm Sgl Ten
DirectionsGPS Friendly
Elementary SchoolRalph Waldo Emerson School 58
High SchoolArsenal Technical High School
High School DistrictIndianapolis Public Schools
Legal DescriptionTuxedo Park L22 B1
Lot Size Square Feet6750
MLS Area4910 - Marion - Center
ModificationTimestamp2025-08-19T23:04:08.168Z
New ConstructionNo
PossessionClosing
Property SubtypeMixed Use
Property TypeCommercial Sale
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive
Tax LotUnknown
Tax Year2024
TownshipCenter
UtilitiesElectricity Connected
Year Built1930
ZoningC-3

Exterior for 4021 E New York Street

Building Area Total3168
Lot Size Acres0.16

Additional Details

Price History

Schools

Middle School N/A
High School Arsenal Technical High School
Elementary School Ralph Waldo Emerson School 58 Elementary School

Nate Simon

REALTOR®, ABR®, SRS, LHC, RENE
Price $329,000
MLS#22057345
List Date 08/19/2025
Property Type Commercial
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 4021 E New York Street